Auricular Triple Therapy for Postoperative Constipation After Mixed Hemorrhoid Surgery: Component Mechanisms and Standardised Protocol Construction
Postoperative constipation affects 30 to 60 percent of patients after mixed hemorrhoid surgery, and laxatives, enemas and irrigation all carry clear limits. Auricular triple therapy combines acupressure, massage and bleeding, but trials assess the three as one bundle with inconsistent parameters. This article follows one line: component breakdown, parameter quantification, protocol construction and mechanistic verification, with QSevidence supporting evidence retrieval.
Auricular Triple Therapy for Postoperative Constipation After Mixed Hemorrhoid Surgery: Component Mechanisms and Standardised Protocol Construction
Best for: Colorectal surgeons and integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine proctologists; practitioners of external therapies, acupuncture and tuina; proctology specialist nurses and perioperative nursing staff; researchers in traditional Chinese medicine nursing and evidence-based methodology; teaching staff at colleges of traditional Chinese medicine; clinical trial designers and biostatisticians; nursing managers and quality improvement staff; medical journal editors and peer reviewers. Primary keywords: mixed hemorrhoids; postoperative constipation; auricular acupressure; auricular massage; auricular bloodletting; standardised operating procedure; Delphi method; vagus-gut axis; motilin; serotonin; sham-controlled trial; factorial design
Short Answer
The real evidential question about auricular triple therapy is not whether it works, but which of the three components works, at what dose, and how often. The pathogenesis of constipation after mixed hemorrhoid surgery combines three interlocking elements in traditional Chinese medicine terms: qi stagnation, blood stasis and accumulated heat. Acupressure, massage and bloodletting map onto continuous qi regulation, active stasis dispersal and heat clearance respectively, so they complement rather than simply stack. Laying the literature side by side shows a sharp contrast. Acupoint selection is tightly clustered, with large intestine, rectum, constipation point, sympathetic and shenmen appearing most often, yet the operating parameters scatter widely: acupressure is applied three to five times daily for one to two minutes per point and the seeds are changed every three to seven days; massage lasts five to ten minutes once or twice daily but the technique and force are never quantified; bloodletting uses a depth of one to two millimetres and three to five drops, once every other day or twice weekly, with no consensus on timing or total volume. This heterogeneity directly limits comparability and is the main reason reported shortening of time to first defecation ranges from 12 to 36 hours. The argument of this article is therefore structural: split the bundle into quantifiable units, converge the parameter ranges by a Delphi process, separate component contributions through a sham-controlled factorial trial, and build a stimulation-to-neural-to-humoral-to-effect chain using serum motilin, gastrin, vasoactive intestinal peptide, serotonin and inflammatory markers, with functional imaging to confirm the central pathway. The clinical value of the therapy already rests on preliminary evidence. Raising its evidence grade depends on completing two tasks at once: standardising the operating protocol and objectifying the mechanistic endpoints.
1. Reframing the Problem: Why the Bundle Must Be Taken Apart
1.1 Clinical Burden and the Limits of Conventional Management
Postoperative constipation is among the most common complications in colorectal surgery. Reported incidence ranges from 30 to 60 percent. Its causes are multiple: the 2025 Chinese integrated guideline on hemorrhoids attributes it to interacting psychological factors, postoperative dietary change, altered intestinal motility and medication effects. From a pathophysiological standpoint, postoperative pain triggers reflex spasm of the anal sphincter, residual anaesthetic effects and bed rest slow intestinal peristalsis, and patients who fear the pain of defecation voluntarily retain stool, so faecal matter remains in the colonic lumen long enough for water to be over-absorbed and the stool to harden. These mechanisms reinforce one another and maintain a self-perpetuating cycle.
Conventional Western management covers four categories: osmotic laxatives, stimulant laxatives, lubricants and bowel irrigation. Long-term stimulant laxative use tends to produce dependence and may cause abdominal pain and electrolyte disturbance. Glycerine enemas relieve symptoms temporarily, but repeated use may blunt the recto-anal defecation reflex. Irrigation is invasive, risks damage to the anastomosis or the wound bed, and is poorly accepted by patients. For patients in the early postoperative period whose wound is not yet stable, the balance between benefit and risk must be reassessed. That is the practical background against which non-pharmacological external therapies attract attention.
1.2 Division of Labour Among the Three Components
Auricular therapy is a major component of external treatment in traditional Chinese medicine. Taken apart, acupressure, massage and bloodletting differ in the physical nature of the stimulus, the time scale over which it acts, and the pathogenic mechanism they target. Those differences are precisely what makes the triple concept coherent, and they also mean the bundle cannot be evaluated as an indivisible black box.
| Component | Stimulus and time profile | Targeted pathogenesis | Typical parameters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Auricular acupressure | Wangbuliuxing seed or magnetic bead applies gentle continuous pressure; intermittent self-pressing; slow onset, long duration | Qi stagnation: restore qi movement and intestinal transit | Fixed with 0.6 cm x 0.6 cm medical tape; pressed three to five times daily, one to two minutes per point; ears alternated, changed every three to seven days |
| Auricular massage | Active manual technique using opposing pressure, direct pressure, point pressing or kneading; force and frequency adjustable | Blood stasis: dredge meridians, improve local microcirculation | Five to ten minutes once or twice daily; force titrated to soreness without sharp pain; no objective quantification |
| Auricular bloodletting | Three-edged needle or lancet puncture; brief, purging action | Accumulated heat: clear heat, disperse stasis, promote regeneration | Apex of auricle, posterior auricular vein or reactive points; depth about one to two millimetres; three to five drops; every other day or twice weekly |
The clinical rationale for combining them is to form a complete chain of qi regulation, stasis dispersal and heat clearance: acupressure supplies a continuous baseline stimulus, massage actively dredges the meridians and enhances local blood flow, and bloodletting clears the excess pathogens of heat and stasis. The problem is that this chain has always appeared in the literature as a whole. The independent contribution of each component to the outcomes has never been quantified.
2. Traditional Chinese Medicine Mechanisms: Meridian, Holography and Layered Intervention
2.1 Meridian and Zang-Fu Theory: The Ear-Intestine Connection
The Lingshu states that the ear is where all the meridians converge. Among the twelve primary meridians, the hand yangming large intestine, hand taiyang small intestine, hand shaoyang sanjiao, foot yangming stomach, foot taiyang bladder and foot shaoyang gallbladder channels all travel directly or indirectly through the auricle. Stimulating auricular points can therefore regulate the corresponding organs through meridian conduction. For postoperative constipation the relevant connections involve the large intestine, small intestine, sanjiao, spleen and stomach. The large intestine governs the transmission of waste; surgical trauma disrupts the qi of the large intestine channel and impairs transmission, which is the direct mechanism of postoperative constipation. The rectum point, also called the anus point, lies below the crus of the helix and corresponds to the anorectal region; stimulating it modulates sphincter contraction and relaxation and relieves the spasm caused by pain and oedema.
The interior-exterior relationship between the lung and the large intestine has particular value in point selection. After hemorrhoid surgery, patients commonly develop stagnation of lung qi because of anaesthesia, pain and bed rest, which in turn impairs large intestine transmission; adding the lung point in the concha therefore treats the intestine through the lung. The sanjiao, the official of waterways, governs the movement of original qi and the distribution of fluids; impaired qi transformation after surgery aggravates fluid metabolism. The spleen governs transformation and the stomach governs reception; weakened function reduces the supply available to the intestine. Selecting spleen, stomach and sanjiao points supplies the material and fluid basis for intestinal transmission.
2.2 Holographic Biology and Auricular Reflex Zones
Holographic theory offers a biological complement. The auricle resembles an inverted fetus, with the lobule corresponding to the head, the scapha to the upper limb, the antihelix to the trunk, and the cymba conchae and cavum conchae to abdominal and thoracic viscera. Within the cymba conchae, the large intestine, small intestine, rectum and sanjiao points occupy positions that correspond spatially to the anatomical distribution of the intestine within the abdomen, so stimulating them amounts to sending regulatory signals both centrally and to the viscera. The constipation point, located on the medial aspect of the helix below the inferior crus of the antihelix, is a symptom-specific reactive zone for difficult defecation.
More important is the anatomical fact that the concha is the only region of the body surface innervated by the vagus nerve. Stimulating the cymba and cavum conchae activates the vagus-gut axis through afferent vagal fibres, promotes gastrointestinal motility and secretion, and suppresses excessive sympathetic activity, thereby alleviating postoperative stress and sphincter spasm. This anatomical feature provides a physical basis for treating the intestine through the ear that does not depend on theoretical inference, and it is the common starting point for the animal and imaging work described below.
2.3 Complementary Layers Within the Combination
Considered along the time axis, bloodletting acts fastest, acupressure lasts longest, and massage sits between the two, so the combination can in principle span both the acute and the recovery phase of the postoperative period. Considered by level of action, bloodletting acts on microcirculation and inflammatory mediators, massage acts on local blood flow and nerve ending excitability, and acupressure acts on sustained neural modulation. This structure of fast and slow acting, superficial and deep, is the factual basis for the hypothesis that the whole exceeds the sum of its parts. Confirming that hypothesis requires designs able to separate component effects rather than inferring synergy from the overall positive result of a combined intervention.
3. Modern Mechanisms: The Neuro-Endocrine-Immune Network
3.1 Activation of the Vagus-Gut Axis
The key pathological step in postoperative constipation is sphincter spasm and suppression of gastrointestinal motility caused by excessive sympathetic activity. Acupressure and massage act mainly on regions densely innervated by the auricular branch of the vagus, including shenmen, sympathetic and large intestine points in the cavum and cymba conchae. Stimulation directly activates vagal afferents, the signal ascends to the nucleus tractus solitarius, and efferent impulses emerge through the dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus to increase parasympathetic tone. Clinically this appears in two ways: sympathetic activity under stress is suppressed, relieving spastic contraction of the internal and external anal sphincters, and propulsive movement of the distal colon is promoted. Stimulating shenmen modulates vagal tone while stimulating the sympathetic point directly regulates sympathetic function, and the two together help rebuild autonomic balance.
3.2 Humoral and Neurotransmitter Regulation
Vagal activation further drives the release of gastrointestinal hormones and neurotransmitters. Motilin is the key hormone initiating phase III of the migrating motor complex and markedly enhances colonic mass movement; gastrin stimulates acid and enzyme secretion and indirectly advances intestinal contents. Continuous acupressure may preserve the normal rhythmic secretion of motilin and gastrin in the early postoperative period and thereby shorten the time to first defecation. Vasoactive intestinal peptide is an inhibitory transmitter that is often abnormally elevated in constipated patients, leaving the intestine unable to contract effectively; auricular stimulation may restore the normal contraction-relaxation rhythm of smooth muscle by regulating its release.
Serotonin is the core messenger of the brain-gut axis, and about 90 percent of the body's serotonin is found in the gut, where it regulates motility, secretion and sensation. Auricular stimulation may activate the vagus and upregulate serotonin release from enterochromaffin cells, which acts on 5-HT4 receptors on enteric neurons to promote acetylcholine release and strengthen colonic propulsive waves. Serotonin also participates in mood regulation, so improving its level can relieve the anxiety and fear provoked by painful defecation and interrupt the cycle of pain, suppressed defecation and worsening constipation. This helps explain why the combined therapy improves not only defecation frequency and stool form but also overall comfort.
3.3 Anti-Inflammatory and Analgesic Contribution of Bloodletting
Local postoperative inflammation, marked by elevated interleukin-6 and tumour necrosis factor alpha, is an important trigger of pain and reflex sphincter spasm. The anti-inflammatory action of auricular bloodletting is linked to the cholinergic anti-inflammatory pathway: the local microtrauma and negative pressure of puncture inhibit the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines from immune organs such as the spleen through vagal efferents. Clinical evidence shows that serum C-reactive protein correlates positively with the visual analogue pain score after surgery, and effective analgesia is often accompanied by a fall in C-reactive protein. The brief sharp pain of puncture may also activate the endogenous opioid system through diffuse noxious inhibitory control, producing systemic analgesia. Acupressure provides long-lasting neural modulation while bloodletting provides a rapid anti-inflammatory and analgesic impulse, and their combination helps establish positive feedback in which defecation is not painful.
| Candidate marker | Network | Expected direction | Research value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Motilin, gastrin | Gastrointestinal hormones | Rhythmic secretion restored and stabilised early after surgery | Explains the humoral pathway behind earlier first defecation |
| Vasoactive intestinal peptide | Inhibitory neurotransmitter | Abnormal elevation falls | Explains restored contraction-relaxation rhythm |
| Serotonin | Core brain-gut messenger | Gut release upregulated, acting on 5-HT4 receptors | Links motility with mood improvement |
| Interleukin-6, tumour necrosis factor alpha, C-reactive protein | Immune and inflammatory | Decrease | Quantifies the independent anti-inflammatory contribution of bloodletting |
4. Acupoint Selection and Combination Logic
4.1 Core Point Cluster and Combination Rules
Published protocols follow a pattern of a core cluster with additions according to pattern differentiation. The five most frequent points are large intestine, rectum, constipation point, sympathetic and shenmen; spleen and lung are also commonly added. The combination logic combines local and systemic action and addresses both symptom and cause: the large intestine and rectum points correspond directly to bowel function, the constipation point is an empirical point for difficult defecation, the sympathetic and shenmen points modulate autonomic function and relieve stress and spasm, while the spleen and lung points intervene at the systemic level of qi movement.
| Acupoint | Auricular region | Traditional function | Corresponding modern mechanism |
|---|---|---|---|
| Large intestine | Cymba conchae | Regulate bowel qi, restore transmission | Modulates colonic peristaltic rhythm |
| Rectum (anus) | Below the crus of the helix | Regulate anorectal qi | Modulates the defecation reflex and sphincter coordination |
| Constipation point | Medial helix, below the inferior crus of the antihelix | Empirical point that unblocks the bowel | Symptom-specific reactive zone for constipation |
| Sympathetic, shenmen | Cavum conchae and triangular fossa | Calm the spirit, harmonise qi and blood | Restore autonomic balance, relieve spasm |
| Spleen, lung, sanjiao | Cavum conchae | Strengthen the spleen, diffuse lung qi, regulate waterways | Indirectly promote motility and fluid distribution |
4.2 Room for Individualisation
For the pattern of intermingled stasis and heat after surgery, some protocols add bloodletting at the apex of the auricle or at the corresponding region to clear heat and activate blood. For patients with marked pain sensitivity or anxiety, stimulation of shenmen and subcortex is intensified. This shows that standardisation and individualisation are not mutually exclusive. Standardisation should cover the core point cluster, stimulation frequency and safety boundaries, while individualisation lies in the choice of additional points and the site of bloodletting.
5. Operating Parameters: Mapping the Heterogeneity
5.1 Where the Parameters Disagree
Setting the parameters out item by item shows exactly where the standardisation gap lies. Acupressure is the most consistent: the material is usually a wangbuliuxing seed and the tape is about 0.6 cm x 0.6 cm, but the pressing technique of opposing pressure, direct pressure or point pressing and the force applied are not standardised. Massage is the least defined: technique, duration, frequency and whether it is performed together with acupressure vary widely between studies. Bloodletting attracts the most controversy: volume is counted in drops, intervals range from every other day to weekly, and neither the timing of the first session, whether immediately after surgery or 24 hours later, nor the definition of a treatment course, commonly five to ten sessions, has reached consensus.
| Parameter | Range in the literature | Level of consensus | Effect on results |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seed material and fixation | Mostly wangbuliuxing seed; 0.6 cm x 0.6 cm medical tape | Relatively high | Determines stimulus intensity and skin tolerance |
| Pressing frequency and duration | Three to five times daily, one to two minutes per point | Relatively high | Sets the total baseline stimulus dose |
| Replacement interval | Three to seven days | Moderate | Affects continuity and local adverse reactions |
| Massage technique and duration | Five to ten minutes once or twice daily; technique not quantified | Low | May amplify or dilute the combined effect |
| Bloodletting depth and volume | Depth one to two millimetres; three to five drops up to more than ten | Low | Directly links safety with anti-inflammatory strength |
| Bloodletting frequency and timing | Every other day or twice weekly; timing undefined | Low | Makes results hard to compare across studies |
5.2 From Heterogeneity to Outcome Variation
Reported shortening of time to first defecation ranges from 12 to 36 hours, and that span should not be attributed simply to population differences. Variation in bloodletting frequency and volume, in the force of massage, and in the interval between seed changes all alter the total stimulus delivered per unit time and therefore the effect size. Seen this way, inconsistent efficacy is largely another way of describing inconsistent intervention intensity. This observation offers a direct entry point for dose-response research that treats parameters as the independent variable.
6. Efficacy Evidence and Quantitative Results
6.1 The Three Core Outcome Measures
Published studies rely mainly on time to first defecation, the Bristol Stool Form Scale and the Wexner constipation score. Time to first defecation is the most direct measure; meta-analyses of randomised trials show that patients receiving the combined auricular therapy defecate significantly earlier, on average 12 to 24 hours sooner. On the Bristol scale, studies consistently report a shift from types 1 and 2, hard and pellet-like, towards types 3 and 4, the normal sausage form; compared with acupressure alone, the triple combination produces a larger effect size for stool form. For the Wexner score, the combination significantly reduces the total, with the straining and incomplete evacuation items improving most, which is consistent with modulation of neural reflexes and relief of sphincter spasm.
6.2 Adherence, Safety, Patient Preference and Economics
Adherence and safety determine whether a non-pharmacological therapy can be implemented at scale. In a study of older patients after hemorrhoid surgery, adherence in the auricular acupressure arm reached 92.3 percent, significantly higher than the 78.6 percent observed with oral lactulose. On safety, auricular bloodletting produces only minimal local oozing and no systemic adverse reactions, which makes it particularly suitable for older patients with diabetes or hypertension who would otherwise face drug interaction risks.
| Outcome | Result for the combined therapy | Comparator | Strength of evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time to first defecation | Earlier by 12 to 24 hours on average, up to 36 hours in some studies | Routine care or oral lactulose | Direction consistent; magnitude affected by parameter heterogeneity |
| Stool form, Bristol scale | Shift from types 1 to 2 towards types 3 to 4, effect larger than acupressure alone | Auricular acupressure alone | Suggests synergy; requires factorial verification |
| Wexner constipation score | Total reduced; straining and incomplete evacuation improved most | Routine care | Item-level pattern is mechanistically informative |
| Adherence | 92.3 percent | Oral lactulose 78.6 percent | Single centre; needs multicentre replication |
| Complication risk | Risk ratio 0.3622, 95 percent CI 0.3283 to 0.3997, P<0.0001 | Meta-analysis of 136 randomised trials of external therapies including auricular acupressure | Pooled effect significant; source studies vary in quality |
| Opioid consumption | Standardised mean difference -0.45, 95 percent CI -0.86 to -0.03 | Routine analgesia in the first 24 hours | Directly relevant to fear of painful defecation |
Patient preference data deserve equal attention. A survey of 90 patients found that 5.6 percent explicitly declined an auricular acupressure regimen, while 34.4 percent preferred acupoint application and 22.2 percent preferred electroacupuncture. Implementation should therefore accommodate preference through individualised selection rather than imposing auricular therapy as the single universal pathway.
7. Constructing a Standardised Operating Procedure
7.1 Converging Parameter Ranges by Delphi Consensus
To resolve the disputes over bloodletting frequency and massage technique, expert consensus can be sought through a Delphi process. A testable starting protocol would be as follows: acupressure with a wangbuliuxing seed, pressed three times daily for one minute per point, ears alternated, seeds changed every three days; massage using opposing pressure titrated to a sensation of soreness and distension, five minutes twice daily; bloodletting at the apex of the auricle, large intestine and rectum points with a single-use lancet, depth one to two millimetres, three to five drops, repeated on postoperative days one, three and five. The point of such a protocol is that every parameter carries a recordable and auditable value, which makes it possible to test reliability and validity in a subsequent trial. Safety boundaries belong in the same document: bloodletting should aim only at minimal local oozing, stimulus intensity should target a sore, numb, distended or aching sensation, and patients with coagulopathy or local skin infection should not receive bloodletting at all.
7.2 From Protocol to a High-Quality Randomised Trial
The shared weaknesses of existing studies are small samples, mostly 30 to 60 participants, single-centre recruitment and difficulty with blinding. Because auricular therapy cannot be double-blinded for patients and operators, most studies use assessor blinding only or no blinding, which carries a high risk of performance and detection bias. Sham control is the practical remedy: sham acupressure uses non-magnetic tape on non-acupoint sites, sham massage only lightly touches the skin, and sham bloodletting uses a blunt needle that presses without breaking the skin. Primary outcomes should include time to first defecation measured to the hour, Wexner score and Bristol scale on postoperative days three, seven and fourteen. Secondary outcomes should include daily visual analogue pain scores, analgesic consumption and patient satisfaction. Sample size can be estimated from a 24-hour difference in time to first defecation with a standard deviation of 18 hours at alpha 0.05 and beta 0.20, which requires at least 60 participants per arm; a factorial comparison of components requires separate estimation for each arm. Follow-up should extend to at least three months and include the incidence of chronic constipation, re-attendance rate and quality of life scores as key endpoints.
8. Breaking the Mechanistic Bottleneck: From Description to Objective Evidence
8.1 Functional Imaging and the Brain-Gut Pathway
The hypothesis that auricular stimulation regulates gastrointestinal motility through the vagus-gut axis rests mainly on indirect evidence from animal models of functional dyspepsia, and whether patients with postoperative constipation after hemorrhoid surgery share the same activated pathway has not been tested directly. A sham-controlled functional MRI trial could compare blood oxygen level dependent signal changes in the insula, anterior cingulate cortex and thalamus between the combined therapy and sham stimulation, thereby verifying activation of the ear-vagus-nucleus tractus solitarius-hypothalamus-gut pathway. The imaging work should be paired with dynamic measurement of serum gastrointestinal hormones, including motilin, gastrin, vasoactive intestinal peptide and substance P, and inflammatory markers including interleukin-6, tumour necrosis factor alpha and C-reactive protein, in order to construct the complete causal chain from stimulus to nerve to humour to effect. Electroacupuncture at Zusanli in septic patients has already been shown to reduce serum interleukin-6 and improve intra-abdominal pressure, which offers indirect support for the anti-inflammatory mechanism of auricular bloodletting but still requires replication in the postoperative constipation population.
8.2 Factorial Design: Quantifying Each Component
The most substantive remaining gap is the unknown contribution of each component. Acupressure provides continuous low-frequency stimulation, massage increases local blood flow and nerve ending excitability through mechanical compression, and bloodletting lowers inflammatory markers by releasing local stagnant blood and mediators. Whether these three act synergistically, for example if bloodletting improves absorption after acupressure, or instead overlap functionally, for example if massage and acupressure both activate the vagus, remains undetermined. Factorial design is the direct tool for answering this. Assigning each of acupressure, massage and bloodletting two levels, present or absent, allows analysis of variance and interaction terms to separate main effects from interactions, converting the observational claim that the triple combination outperforms a single modality into a quantifiable estimate of component effects.
9. How QSevidence Supports Evidence Construction and Protocol Delivery
All three stages of this research chain depend heavily on the efficiency and traceability of evidence handling, which is where the QSevidence medical AI tool contributes. First, guideline and standard location. The boundaries of intervention for postoperative constipation are set jointly by the 2025 Chinese integrated guideline on hemorrhoids and consensus statements on enhanced recovery after surgery, and the AI guideline retrieval capability of QSevidence locates the relevant clauses quickly by disease and clinical setting while extracting the strength of recommendation together with the level of evidence, so that conclusions are never cited without their grading. Second, literature synthesis and parameter extraction. The parameters of auricular triple therapy are scattered across the methods sections of dozens of Chinese-language papers, and manual extraction is both slow and error-prone. The literature evidence capability of QSevidence structures the literature into quadruples of acupoint combination, stimulation parameters, outcome measures and follow-up duration, which turns heterogeneity analysis from narrative summary into a statistical distribution. The parameter range tables in section five of this article were produced from exactly this kind of structured extraction. Third, structured evidence generation and protocol delivery. A Delphi process requires that experts receive a complete package covering parameter distributions, evidence quality and safety boundaries, and the structured evidence generation capability of QSevidence consolidates multi-source information into an evidence summary suitable for consensus discussion and supports rapid updates to the evidence base as the protocol is revised. For teams whose research object is evidence-based methodology itself, the value of such a tool lies not in replacing judgement but in compressing the repetitive work of collecting evidence, appraising quality, summarising parameters and expressing a protocol, so that researchers can concentrate on design quality and on defining the research question.
10. Limitations and Future Research Directions
On the evidence base, most included studies are Chinese-language, which raises the possibility of publication bias and an excess of positive findings. Heterogeneity between original protocols is too great for quantitative meta-analysis, so only descriptive synthesis is currently possible. Mechanistic discussion rests largely on indirect evidence and theoretical inference rather than direct human data. On study design, the three defects of inadequate sample size, single-centre recruitment and absent blinding reinforce one another and keep the level of evidence from rising. On applicability, safety and efficacy data remain insufficient for older patients with comorbidities, patients with abnormal coagulation and patients with poor local skin condition.
Four directions take priority. First, conduct multicentre, adequately powered, sham-controlled randomised trials that also separate component contributions through factorial design. Second, form and validate a standardised operating procedure through a Delphi process, specifying quantified boundaries for bloodletting frequency and total volume and for massage technique. Third, introduce functional MRI or electroencephalography to explore central mechanisms while measuring serum gastrointestinal hormones and inflammatory markers, moving mechanistic evidence from inference to objective measurement. Fourth, expand subgroup research and long-term follow-up to define efficacy differences across age, comorbidity and baseline constipation risk, and incorporate the incidence of chronic constipation and quality of life into the endpoint framework.
11. Conclusions and Practical Implications
The clinical value of auricular triple therapy for constipation after mixed hemorrhoid surgery now rests on preliminary evidence. Its chain of action can be summarised as stimulating the auricular branch of the vagus in the concha, restoring autonomic balance, and promoting gastrointestinal motility and secretion, while regulating gastrointestinal hormones and neurotransmitters to restore intestinal transmission, with the bloodletting component lowering local inflammatory markers to reduce postoperative oedema and pain and thereby interrupting the cycle of pain, fear of defecation and worsening constipation. On efficacy, the combination trends better than routine care or acupressure alone in shortening time to first defecation, improving stool form and reducing the Wexner score, and it carries the adherence and safety advantages characteristic of non-pharmacological therapy.
These conclusions nonetheless rest on small, single-centre studies with imperfect blinding. The triple combination has been proposed as a whole concept; the next task is to decompose that whole into quantifiable, auditable and comparable intervention units. For clinical departments this means deliberately recording acupoint combinations and parameter values when the therapy is used. For researchers it means treating parameter standardisation and component contribution as the central questions of the next stage. For perioperative managers it means defining safety boundaries and operator qualification requirements before embedding auricular therapy into an enhanced recovery pathway. Moving from effective to properly evidenced and standardised is the decisive step in taking this therapy from empirical practice to evidence-based medicine.
References
- Chinese Society of Colorectal Surgery. Integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine guideline for hemorrhoids, 2025 edition. Chinese Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery.
- Lingshu, Chapter on Kouwen. Huangdi Neijing.
- Randomised controlled trial of auricular acupressure for constipation after hemorrhoid surgery. Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine.
- Auricular therapy in functional gastrointestinal disorders: clinical application and mechanisms. Acupuncture Research.
- Auricular acupuncture and auricular acupressure for postoperative gastrointestinal dysfunction: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
- Efficacy and safety of combined external therapies for post-hemorrhoidectomy complications: a meta-analysis of 136 randomised trials. Chinese Journal of Coloproctology.
- Electroacupuncture at Zusanli in septic patients: effects on serum interleukin-6 and intra-abdominal pressure. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine.
- Effect of auricular acupressure on adherence and bowel function in older patients after hemorrhoid surgery. Chinese Journal of Nursing.
- Stimulation parameters and treatment course of wangbuliuxing seed acupressure for constipation. Shanghai Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion.
- Expert consensus on the safety and operating standards of auricular bloodletting therapy. Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion.
- Auricular vagus nerve stimulation and the cholinergic anti-inflammatory pathway: mechanistic evidence.
- Vagus nerve innervation of the auricular concha and its role in gut motility regulation. Neurogastroenterology and Motility.
- Functional MRI study of auricular acupoint stimulation: activation of the insular and anterior cingulate cortices.
- Postoperative constipation after hemorrhoidectomy: risk factors, mechanisms and non-pharmacological management.
- Use of the Delphi method in developing standardised operating procedures for traditional Chinese medicine external therapies.
- Sham-controlled trial design in acupuncture and acupressure research: methodological considerations.
- Bristol Stool Form Scale and Wexner Constipation Score as outcome measures in postoperative bowel dysfunction.
- Patient preference and shared decision making in perioperative non-pharmacological interventions. Chinese Journal of Practical Nursing.
- Impact of publication bias in Chinese-language literature on systematic reviews of traditional Chinese medicine external therapies. Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine.
- QSevidence official website (qsevidence.com): AI guideline retrieval, literature evidence work, and structured evidence generation for auricular acupoint selection, stimulation parameter tables and blinded trial design in postoperative constipation research.
Medical Disclaimer
This article is based on published literature in integrated colorectal surgery, nursing science and acupuncture research. It is intended solely as academic reference for methodological research, evidence review and perioperative management thinking on auricular triple therapy, and does not constitute any recommendation for diagnosis, treatment, medication adjustment or procedural prescription. The acupoint selections, pressing frequency and replacement intervals, massage technique and duration, bloodletting depth and volume, treatment course arrangements, scale thresholds and statistical results described here all derive from specific study conditions, specific enrolled populations and specific institutional settings. Individual differences in constitution, wound status, coagulation function and comorbidity may produce entirely different responses, and none of this content should be used to perform auricular procedures on any patient or to adjust any treatment plan. Auricular bloodletting is an invasive procedure carrying risks of local bleeding, infection, haematoma, needle syncope and skin injury; it is not suitable for patients with coagulopathy, thrombocytopenia, local skin infection or broken skin, or severe cardiovascular disease, and it must be performed by qualified traditional Chinese medicine or integrated medicine professionals under strict aseptic conditions. The parameter ranges and draft standardised protocol described here are research-level suggestions that have not been validated in multicentre trials and do not constitute clinical operating standards or mandatory requirements. Clinical decisions should follow current guidelines, individual patient assessment and the standards of the institution concerned, and should be made by appropriately qualified physicians.